Visualizing Mastodon server moderation

In Mapping the wider fediverse I showed how a new table added to the Mastodon plugin—mastodon_domain_block—enables queries that find which servers are moderating which other servers. For example, here are servers on nerdculture.de’s list of offenders.

select
  server,
  domain,
  severity
from
  mastodon_domain_block
where
  server = 'https://nerdculture.de'

+------------------------+--------------------------------+----------+
| server                 | domain                         | severity |
+------------------------+--------------------------------+----------+
| https://nerdculture.de | roysbeer.place                 | silence  |
| https://nerdculture.de | *.10minutepleroma.com          | suspend  |
| https://nerdculture.de | *.activitypub-troll.cf         | suspend  |

...snip...

| https://nerdculture.de | shitposter.club                | suspend  |
| https://nerdculture.de | wolfgirl.bar                   | suspend  |
| https://nerdculture.de | www2.gabbers.me                | suspend  |
+------------------------+--------------------------------+----------+

I used the new query pattern to build a dashboard to report, for each server in the home timeline:

• The list of blocking servers.
• The count of blocked servers for each blocking server.
• The list of blocking servers for each blocked server, and the count of those blocking servers.

This was a good start, but I had a hunch that relationship graphs would reveal non-obvious connections among these servers. And indeed they do! Here’s a view of the new graph-enriched dashboard.

IDG

The left pane shows the blocked servers shunned by a blocking server selected from those in the home timeline. The right pane has the inverse view: the blocking servers that shun a selected blocked server. These were the two categories I defined for the first iteration of these graphs.

category "blocking_server" {
  color = "darkgreen"
  icon = "server"
}

category "blocked_server" {
  color = "darkred"
  icon = "server"
}

Here’s the code for one of the graphs.

graph {
   node {
    base = node.blocking_server
  }
   node {
    base = node.blocked_server
  }
   node {
    base = node.blocked_and_blocking_server
  }
   edge {
    args = [ self.input.blocking_server.value ]
    base = edge.match_blocked_server
  }
   edge {
    args = [ self.input.blocking_server.value ]
    base = edge.match_blocking_server
  }
}

Here is the definition of node.blocking_server, which refers to category.blocking_server.

node "blocking_server" {
  category = category.blocking_server
  sql = <<EOQ
    with servers as (
      select distinct
        blocking_server,
        blocked_server
      from
        blocking_servers(${local.limit})
    )
    select
      blocking_server as id,
      blocking_server as title
    from
      servers
    order by
      blocking_server
  EOQ
}

The FROM clause calls blocking_servers(), a set-returning function defined like so:

create or replace function public.blocking_servers(max int) returns table (
  blocking_server text,
  blocked_server text
) as $$
with servers as (
  select distinct
    server as domain,
    'https://' || server as server_url
  from
    mastodon_toot
  where
    timeline = 'home'
  limit max
),
blocking_and_blocked as (
  select
    s.domain as blocking_domain,
    d.domain as blocked_domain
  from
    servers s
  join
    mastodon_domain_block d
  on
    s.server_url = d.server
)
select
  blocking_domain,
  blocked_domain
from
  blocking_and_blocked
order by
  blocking_domain, blocked_domain
$$ language sql

I thought these ingredients would suffice. But when I began poking around in the graphs made with these definitions, infosec.exchange behaved strangely. Sometimes it would appear as a blocking server, other times as a blocked server. I was missing a category!

category "blocked_and_blocking_server" {
  color = "orange"
  icon = "server"
}

As you can see in the graph, infosec.exchange not only blocks 73 servers, it is also blocked by two servers: religion.masto.host and weatherishappening.net. Why?

weatherishappening.net calls infosec.exchange a “HOSTING DEATH SPIRAL FASCIST ORGANIZATION” and blocks it with “Limited” severity.

religion.masto.host blocks infosec.exchange at the “Suspended” level, but does not explain why (“Reason not available”).

Although those servers could, in turn, be blocked by others, no such blocks appear in the block lists of my immediate server neighborhood.

> select count(*) from blocking_servers(100) where blocked_server = 'weatherishappening.net'
+-------+
| count |
+-------+
| 0     |
+-------+

> select count(*) from blocking_servers(100) where blocked_server = 'religion.masto.host'
+-------+
| count |
+-------+
| 0     |
+-------+

There is another switch hitter in my neighborhood, though. c.im is blocked by me.dm and octodon.social.

IDG

Why?

me.dm (Medium) has “Suspended” c.im for “Hate speech”.

octodon.social has “Suspended” c.im for “Reason not available”.

When the opinions and policies of your server differ from those of mine, we see different realities through our respective lenses. Could such fragmentation drive the fediverse-curious back into the arms of Big Social? I’m sure that will happen—indeed is happening—to some degree.

But I hope that some of us, at least, will learn to thrive in diverse networks of online communities, aware of the kaleidoscopic interplay of filters but not overwhelmed by it. That skill will serve us well IRL too. To acquire it, we’ll need to visualize the operation of our filters. One great way to do that: SQL queries that drive relationship graphs.

This series:

1. Autonomy, packet size, friction, fanout, and velocity
2. Mastodon, Steampipe, and RSS
3. Browsing the fediverse
4. A Bloomberg terminal for Mastodon
5. Create your own Mastodon UX
6. Lists and people on Mastodon
7. How many people in my Mastodon feed also tweeted today?
8. Instance-qualified Mastodon URLs
9. Mastodon relationship graphs
10. Working with Mastodon lists
11. Images considered harmful (sometimes)
12. Mapping the wider fediverse
13. Protocols, APIs, and conventions
14. News in the fediverse
15. Mapping people and tags in Mastodon
16. Visualizing Mastodon server moderation
17. Mastodon timelines for teams
18. The Mastodon plugin is now available on the Steampipe Hub